Ctrl+k

Compare data values from different distributions

Comparing values from different distributions requires interpreting each value relative to its distribution’s center and variability, not merely comparing the raw numbers. Standardizing with a z-score, z=(xmean)/standard deviationz=(x-\text{mean})/\text{standard deviation}, or using percentile position allows relative standing to be compared across differing scales and units; a larger z-score indicates a higher position within its distribution. The comparison should account for distribution shape and distinguish relative position from absolute magnitude, without extending to advanced inferential tests or modeling.

Detailed Explanation: Compare data values from different distributions

To compare a value from one distribution with a value from another, compare how far each value is from its own distribution’s mean. A useful measure is the z-score:

z=xmeanstandard deviationz=\frac{x-\text{mean}}{\text{standard deviation}}

A larger z-score means the value is relatively higher within its distribution.

Example

A student receives:

  • 82 on a mathematics test. The class mean is 75, with a standard deviation of 5.
  • 91 on a history test. The class mean is 85, with a standard deviation of 10.

Which score is higher relative to its class?

Step 1: Find the mathematics z-score

zmath=82755=75=1.4z_{\text{math}}=\frac{82-75}{5} =\frac{7}{5} =1.4

The mathematics score is 1.41.4 standard deviations above the class mean.

Step 2: Find the history z-score

zhistory=918510=610=0.6z_{\text{history}}=\frac{91-85}{10} =\frac{6}{10} =0.6

The history score is 0.60.6 standard deviations above the class mean.

Step 3: Compare the z-scores

1.4>0.61.4>0.6

Therefore, the mathematics score is higher relative to its class, even though the raw history score, 9191, is greater than the mathematics score, 8282.

The mathematics class has less variability, so being 77 points above its mean represents a stronger relative performance than being 66 points above the history mean. This comparison assumes that z-scores are reasonable summaries for the distributions, such as when the distributions are not extremely skewed or affected by unusual outliers.

Learn by doing: Compare data values from different distributions

Click a topic below to practice the foundational skills you'll need, learn the steps, or master this skill

Practice with unlimited practice problems

Statistics - Standard Deviation - Two Value Sets to Better Performance


    ?